Employee A vs Employee B: The Trustworthiness That Decides Who Gets Promoted

    Two employees. Same skills, same opportunities. One keeps her word even when no one is watching; the other bends the truth under pressure. Here is why Employee A ends up running the department — and Employee B ends up running out of chances.

    Employee A vs Employee B: The Trustworthiness That Decides Who Gets Promoted

    Employee A vs Employee B: The Trustworthiness That Decides Who Gets Promoted

    Two employees join the same company on the same day, with roughly the same skills. Five years later, one of them is running a department. The other has quietly been passed over three times. The difference was never talent — it was whether people could trust what they said and did when nobody was checking.

    In short

    Where this sits on your Winning Kite

    Integrity and Trustworthiness is the fifth trait on the EQ — left — side of your Winning Kite (KITE Leadership Framework). A kite needs balance on all four sides — EQ, RQ, PQ, and Success — to fly steady. Trustworthiness is one of the strings that holds the left side taut. Lose it, and the whole kite starts to spin, no matter how strong your skills (PQ) or your network (RQ) are.

    The Table That Changes How You See Your Own Career

    In my corporate training sessions, I put up a simple table. It never fails to make the room go quiet, because everyone recognises someone in it — sometimes themselves.

    Employee A — TrustworthyEmployee B — Untrustworthy
    Keeps promises, even when it's hardMakes commitments but doesn't follow through
    Admits mistakes immediately, without excusesHides mistakes, blames others, makes excuses
    Confronts colleagues who break rulesStays silent when colleagues act unethically
    Transparent about challenges and limitationsHides information to close deals or avoid conflict
    Follows rules even under pressureBends rules under pressure or self-interest
    Works with the same integrity whether supervised or notPerforms differently when supervised vs unsupervised

    Over time, Employee A earns trust, respect, and bigger responsibilities. Employee B may succeed in the short term — closing a deal by hiding a flaw, hitting a deadline by skipping a step — but eventually loses credibility and opportunities. The gap doesn't show up in month one. It shows up in year five, when Employee A is the one being handed the confidential project, and Employee B is the one being quietly worked around.

    The HOD Who Taught Me Trustworthiness Before I Had a Career

    I still remember my college days in Pune. Our Head of Department, Mr. Anandrao Deshmukh, was known across campus for one thing — his unbending strictness about rules and punctuality.

    Back then, I didn't appreciate it. In fact, I resented it.

    He wouldn't bend the rules for anyone. Not for the brightest student. Not for someone with a family emergency. Not even for his own favourites. If you were late, you were marked absent. If your attendance fell below the required percentage, you were detained. No exceptions. No negotiations.

    I got detained once because of low attendance. I was furious. I blamed him for being harsh, inflexible, unfair. "He's too strict," I complained to my friends. "He doesn't understand students' problems."

    But years later, when I started my own business and began training professionals across India, something shifted.

    I realised Mr. Deshmukh's discipline wasn't cruelty — it was integrity. He didn't cut corners. He held everyone to the same standard, no matter who they were. That unbending sense of right and wrong was what made him trustworthy. And ironically, the very strictness I disliked has become a principle I deeply admire.

    If he had bent the rules for "important students," we would never have learned why trustworthiness matters. That's the uncomfortable truth about Employee A behaviour — it rarely feels good in the moment. It feels good years later, when your reputation is the thing carrying you.

    What Trustworthiness Actually Means

    Trustworthiness is simple to define but rare to witness: it means being genuinely reliable — doing what you say, following the rules, and standing up for what's right, even when no one is watching.

    It's about transparency. Admitting your mistakes. Confronting unethical behaviour in others. Acting consistently with your values, not just when it's convenient, but especially when it's hard.

    In the workplace, trustworthiness translates into one powerful reality: people know they can count on you. And that changes everything.

    Why It Matters More Than Talent

    Trustworthiness opens doors that skill alone cannot:

    You earn respect. When you consistently keep your word, clients, colleagues, and bosses notice. That respect paves the way for promotions and leadership roles.

    You build strong relationships. Customers return to you because they trust your honesty. Teammates feel safe sharing their problems because they know you won't betray them.

    You enhance your credibility. In times of crisis — looming deadlines, angry clients, tough sales targets — trustworthy people stand out. They don't panic or deceive. They find solutions without sacrificing their values.

    Trustworthiness isn't about being perfect. It's about being consistent.

    When Is Trustworthiness Actually Tested?

    Anyone can be honest when life is smooth. The real test comes when you're under pressure — a crushing deadline, an angry client, tough sales goals. That's when people think, "Let me just fudge this a bit to fix it quickly." But the moment you do that, you risk breaking the trust you've spent years building.

    In sales: you're closing a deal, and the client asks about a feature your product doesn't have. Do you hide the truth to close the sale, or admit the limitation and offer alternatives?

    In quality control: you're a quality head in a pharma company, under immense pressure to release a batch on time. One test result is borderline. Do you follow the SOP and delay, or skip the retest and push it through?

    In admitting mistakes: you made an error that affected a project timeline. Do you own it immediately, or deflect blame, give excuses, and hide behind circumstances?

    The more stressful the situation, the more critical it is to stand by your ethics. When you do, you prove that you can be counted on — no matter how difficult things get. This is exactly the line between Employee A and Employee B: not what they do when it's easy, but what they do when it costs them something.

    Integrity Without Supervision: The Ultimate Test

    Most workplaces have supervision — someone watching, checking, monitoring. But what about when no one is watching? That's the ultimate test of integrity.

    In Bangalore, there's a man named Trivikrama Mahadeva whose work has quietly touched countless lives. Over the years, Trivikrama has performed the last rites and burials for over one lakh deceased individuals — unclaimed bodies, people without families, those forgotten by society.

    His work doesn't follow a 9-to-5 schedule. Sometimes he gets calls at odd hours — late evening, early dawn. No matter the time, he goes to the location, collects the body, and carries out the burial or cremation with dignity.

    Here's what makes Trivikrama extraordinary: there's no boss telling him what to do. No manager checking if he's really doing it. Yet he never fails to show up. He has complete freedom to decide when or how to do his job, yet he never misuses that freedom. He ensures every burial is done with respect and care — as if he's performing it for his own family member.

    His self-driven honesty reflects genuine trustworthiness. We often talk about integrity in office jobs. But here is a person whose work is far from the spotlight — and still, he embodies integrity day after day. His actions remind us that real trustworthiness isn't about the job title or salary. It's about doing the right thing, consistently, because you believe in it. When no one else is looking, true character shines brightest.

    A Real Story: Gauri's Choice

    Gauri joined our company in 2016. She's taken a few breaks over the years — for pregnancy, child-rearing — but each time, she returned with the same commitment and loyalty.

    One event revealed her true character.

    An old client — who'd worked with Gauri before — reached out to her directly when she wasn't employed with us. The client needed services and likely assumed Gauri would handle the job independently and pocket the payment herself.

    But Gauri made a different choice. She served the client as usual, without cutting corners. And then she invoiced the transaction under our company's name, not her own.

    She didn't profit personally. But she proved something far more valuable: her strong sense of integrity and loyalty. Because of moments like these, Gauri now manages some of our most important financial and compliance tasks. Not because she had fancy qualifications from the start, but because her trustworthiness stood out.

    She began as an underconfident newcomer, unsure of her future. Today, she's become irreplaceable — all thanks to her unwavering commitment to honesty. This is Employee A, in the flesh: the client offered her a Employee B shortcut, and she declined it without being asked to.

    A Quiet Example: Arjun

    In our organisation, there's Arjun, an office assistant who's been with us for eight years. He doesn't have a managerial title. But his trustworthiness is extraordinary.

    If he sees someone bypassing rules, he doesn't hesitate to speak up. He ensures no one misuses office resources. He doesn't think, "I'm just an office boy — why should I care?" Instead, he shows that integrity isn't tied to your position. It's tied to your character.

    Many times, I've seen colleagues more senior than him take note of his honesty and consult him on important details. It's a reminder that trustworthiness at any level can have a huge impact on team morale and work culture.

    Being trustworthy also means not ignoring wrongdoing when you see it. Yes, it feels awkward to speak up if a colleague is bending the rules or inflating expenses. But staying silent means you're not truly supporting the workplace's ethical standards. When you bravely address such problems, you show that fairness matters. Your colleagues learn that wrong behaviour won't be tolerated — which makes the work environment more honest and less stressful for everyone. Arjun could easily have been Employee B — low visibility, low accountability, easy to stay silent. He chose Employee A instead, and it changed how the whole office sees him.

    Why Do Professionals Slide Toward Employee B?

    If integrity is so valuable, why do so many professionals struggle with it?

    1. Short-term thinking. They prioritise immediate gains over long-term credibility. Cutting corners feels easier in the moment, but it erodes trust over time.

    2. Pressure and fear. Under stress, people panic. They think bending the rules will save them. But it usually creates bigger problems later.

    3. Lack of role models. If you've never seen integrity modelled consistently, it's harder to practice it yourself.

    4. Self-interest over team interest. When personal gain conflicts with organisational values, many choose themselves. They rationalise it as "everyone does it."

    5. No consequences for dishonesty. In some workplaces, unethical behaviour goes unpunished. This creates a culture where integrity feels optional.

    But here's the truth: trustworthiness is never optional if you want lasting success.

    The Cost of Lost Integrity

    When you compromise your integrity, you don't just lose trust — you lose opportunities, relationships, and peace of mind.

    I've seen senior executives lose major clients because they hid crucial information. I've watched talented professionals get sidelined because they couldn't be trusted with confidential projects. I've coached managers whose teams fell apart because no one believed their promises anymore.

    Rebuilding trust is far harder than maintaining it. One moment of dishonesty can erase years of good work. This is the compounding math behind the Employee A vs Employee B table: Employee A's small consistent choices add up slowly; Employee B's one big lapse can subtract everything at once.

    Howard Gardner's Four Mirror Tests

    Harvard psychologist Howard Gardner, in his work on cultivating an ethical mind, suggests four signposts to check and improve our trustworthiness. I use a version of this framework as inspiration in my own training — a light nod to a respected idea, not a replacement for the Winning Kite that anchors everything I teach.

    1. Mission Test. What do you want to achieve with your work? Whether you're a teacher, accountant, salesperson, or designer — what's your purpose? Having a clear mission helps you stay aligned with your values, even under pressure.

    2. Role Models Test. Who do you follow? Positive role models show you the right attitude, ethics, and behaviour to emulate. Negative role models teach you what to avoid. Choose your influences carefully.

    3. Personal Mirror Test. Look at yourself in the mirror. Can you say with complete honesty that you're working with 100% transparency? Are you following all rules and regulations? Are you cutting corners, or are you doing the right thing even when it's hard?

    4. Professional Mirror Test. How are you treating people who are trustworthy and loyal in your organisation? Are you recognising their contributions? And equally important — are you confronting individuals who are causing harm or acting unethically? If you're a manager, this is your responsibility.

    These four tests are not one-time exercises. They're daily reflections. Keep asking yourself these questions, and you'll build a strong ethical foundation.

    How to Move Yourself Toward Employee A

    Trustworthiness isn't an inherent trait — it's a habit you build through consistent practice.

    1. Start with small promises. Keep every commitment, no matter how small. If you say you'll send an email by 3 PM, send it by 3 PM. Small actions build your reputation over time.

    2. Admit mistakes immediately. Don't wait. Don't deflect. Don't make excuses. Own your errors openly and focus on fixing them. People respect honesty far more than perfection.

    3. Speak up against wrongdoing. If you see something unethical, don't stay silent. Address it directly and respectfully. Your courage sets the tone for others — this is exactly what Arjun does.

    4. Do the right thing when no one is watching. This is where true integrity lives. Follow the same standards whether you're supervised or working alone. Your character is tested in private, not in public — this is exactly what Trivikrama Mahadeva does.

    5. Align your actions with your values. Write down your core values. Then audit your behaviour. Are your daily actions consistent with what you say you believe? If not, make changes.

    6. Build a circle of accountability. Surround yourself with people who hold you to high standards. Ask trusted colleagues or mentors to give you honest feedback on your integrity.

    7. Use the Front-Page Test. Before making a decision, ask yourself: if this were on tomorrow's front page, would I be proud? If the answer is no, reconsider your choice.

    Final Reflection

    Integrity is the foundation of everything else. Without it, your skills don't matter. Your intelligence doesn't matter. Your ambition doesn't matter.

    Because if people can't trust you, they won't follow you. They won't do business with you. They won't promote you. They won't recommend you.

    But when you consistently show up with honesty, transparency, and courage — even when it's hard — you build something far more valuable than any promotion or pay raise. You build a reputation. And a reputation built on integrity is unshakeable.

    Psychologist Daniel Goleman's work on emotional intelligence has long pointed out that self-awareness and self-regulation are what let people act ethically under pressure — a useful supporting idea, though the specific Employee A vs Employee B lens and the Winning Kite structure around it are entirely from my own training practice and this book.

    So here's my question for you: when no one is watching, who are you? Because that's who you really are. If your organisation is trying to build a culture full of Employee A's — and fewer Employee B's — this is exactly the conversation I help leadership teams have in my Signature Programs and corporate training sessions.

    Bring These Ideas to Your Team

    Avinash Chate turns the traits in Stars at India Inc. into live leadership & emotional-intelligence workshops. TEDx speaker · 11+ yrs training Army, BRO, RBI, BARC, JSW & 1000+ leaders.

    ✅ Thanks! Avinash team will reach out within 24 hours.

    '}).catch(function(e){f.outerHTML='

    Something went wrong. WhatsApp +91 8793630001

    '});return false;">Select ServiceKeynote / Motivational SpeakingLeadership Development TrainingTeam Building WorkshopManager DevelopmentEmployee TrainingBook Avinash Now →

    Or WhatsApp directly: +91 87936 30001

    Work with Avinash Chate

    Avinash Chate

    TEDx Speaker · Founder, The Future Corporate · Author of Stars at India Inc.

    Avinash has trained the Indian Army, BRO, RBI, BARC, JSW Steel and 1000+ corporate leaders across India. His work focuses on leadership, emotional intelligence and behavioural training rooted in Indian values and modern business needs.

    Frequently Asked Questions

    What is the difference between Employee A and Employee B in terms of trustworthiness?

    Employee A (trustworthy) keeps promises even when it's hard, admits mistakes without excuses, confronts colleagues who break rules, stays transparent about limitations, follows rules under pressure, and behaves the same whether supervised or not. Employee B (untrustworthy) makes commitments but doesn't follow through, hides mistakes and blames others, stays silent about unethical behaviour, hides information to close deals, bends rules under pressure, and performs differently when watched versus unwatched.

    Why does trustworthiness matter more than talent at work?

    Talent gets you noticed once. Trustworthiness gets you trusted repeatedly — with bigger projects, confidential information, and leadership roles. Skills without integrity eventually get sidelined because people can't rely on you when it counts. Over time, trustworthy people like Employee A earn compounding responsibility, while untrustworthy people like Employee B lose credibility even after early success.

    How can I test my own trustworthiness at work?

    Use Howard Gardner's four mirror tests: the Mission Test (do you know your purpose?), the Role Models Test (who are you learning ethics from?), the Personal Mirror Test (are you 100% transparent with yourself?), and the Professional Mirror Test (do you recognise trustworthy colleagues and confront unethical ones?). Also try the Front-Page Test — before any decision, ask if you'd be proud to see it reported tomorrow.

    Where does trustworthiness fit in the Winning Kite framework?

    Integrity and Trustworthiness is the fifth trait on the EQ (Emotional Intelligence) — left — side of the Winning Kite. Without it, your RQ (relationships) and your Success (top) both become unstable, because no one fully trusts someone whose word and behaviour aren't consistent.

    Related Articles by Avinash Chate

    Avinash Chate services

    Corporate Trainer in Bengaluru · Top Corporate Trainers in India · Leadership Trainer in Bengaluru · Top Leadership Trainers in India · Team Building Trainer in Bengaluru · Top Team Building Trainers in India · Motivational Speaker in Bengaluru · Top Motivational Speakers in India · All service locations

    ← Back to all articles · Book Avinash Chate

    By Avinash Chate — Maharashtra’s #1 Corporate Trainer & Motivational Speaker. .